Monday, April 17, 2017

Train Operations

Since one of the big questions on my mind concerning railroads was how did they operate. I'm going to save details I come across in this posting until eventually the "big picture" will become evident. One of the complications is that the answer before 1970s (no interstate, unit trains, or intermodal) are different from the answer after the 1970s. So we will see how the information unfolds. I'm also using this for historical tidbits that are not significant enough or understood well enough for their own posting.

CN interchanging with BRC and IHB plus autotrains.

Question: Does anybody remember when SP purchased the ex-GM&O line to Springfield from I believe the Chicago, Missouri & Western? If so, how did SP access Clearing?

Comments indicate the Rock Island commuter branch used to be along 95th instead of 89th.

C&WI Canal Street Yard in comments

Terminal and belt line operations

LS&BC and Midway junction (I contributed)

Hussey Termina Railroad Company in North Chicago

C&WI looking east at 86th even with the comments I still can't figure out where this is at

Area south of Corwith

Article about Wabash installing CTC

An example of coal bunkers for residential and small business service before compressors where developed to pump natural gas long distances. (Manufactured gas was used for lighting, not heating.)

From http://cs.trains.com/trn/f/111/t/109761.aspx:
Posted by bn13814 on Thursday, November 15, 2007 11:34 AM
No eastern road, except Conrail, actually "gave up" their route to Peoria over the years.
The Pennsylvania RR let TP&W handle most east-west traffic for them between East Peoria and Effner. The Penn Central merger in 1968 led to the diversion of the small amount of through traffic still handled by the PRR Terre Haute - Farmdale Jct. line to the Peoria & Eastern. A portion of the line between Atlanta and Waynesville was embargoed after a 1973 washout. The Maroa - Farmdale Jct. portion was then sold to Illinois Terminal on April 1, 1976. IT was a north-south oriented Regional.
Conrail closed the Olin (IN) to Crawfordsville (IN) segment of the former Peoria & Eastern (operated by New York Central and predecessor Big Four since 1890) Indianapolis - Pekin mainline in 1981 after it was discovered the Wabash River was undercutting the railroad bridge spanning it. The daily pair of manifests - INPE and PEIN - were diverted via Terre Haute. Flooding caused washouts near Mackinaw in the fall of 1983, which led to a permanent diversion of INPE and PEIN to the Norfolk & Western west of Bloomington sometime in 1984. Conrail put the "Pekin Secondary" up for sale in 1991, but took it off the block after talks with Pioneer Railcorp fell through in 1992. The lines were for sale again in 1995 and after sale to Norfolk Southern of the Bloomington - Urbana segment the following year, Conrail replaced direct service to Peoria with a haulage deal (NS handled there traffic between Lafayette and East Peoria) lasting to the breakup in 1999.
Norfolk & Western decided to close the Lafayette - Gibson City section of its old NKP line to through traffic in late 1986, rerouting everything via Decatur (not Chicago) instead. classification of Peoria and Bloomington-Normal traffic at Decatur made sense because both north-south traffic inherited from ITC in 1982 and east-west former NKP traffic could be handled there.
The TP&W served as a major east-west bridge route from 1927 to 1981. It's eastern connection with Conrail at Logansport (shifted from Penn Central at Effner in 1976, after acquiring the former PRR Effner Branch that year) was cut off after Conrail canceled joint rates that made Logansport an interchange point. Most rates included the Santa Fe as well, but TP&W interchanged much traffic generated in the Peoria area with Conrail as well. Ironically, the Conrail Transaction has somewhat restored TP&W's eastern outlet, though rather than being NS at Logansport, the shortline's major eastern interchange is with CSXT at Lafayette.
Railroads began de-emphasizing Peoria as a major Gateway following the C&NW's takeover of the M&StL in 1960. That diverted a large chunk of business away from the NKP, NYC, TP&W and even PRR. Improved connections at Chicago betwen eastern and western roads caused the CB&Q and NYC to reduce their Peoria interchange by the late 1960's. The N&W+NKP+WAB merger led to N&W trying to bypass the TP&W and interchange directly with the AT&SF at Kansas City. Reduced traffic and deferred maintenance led to fewer trains on the N&W Peoria District from 1965. A decline in perishable and meat traffic (diversion to COFC and trucks) cut out a lot of CB&Q-N&W interchange by 1970.
By 1970, TP&W was the only carrier here handling a significant amount of east-west overhead traffic. P&E and N&W were mainly (though not entirely) dependent on traffic moving to and from the Peoria-Pekin Switching District. N&W did, however, have a small, but steady amout of interchange with BN through the decade (forest products, sand, frozen foods, aluminum ingots, etc.).
With deregulation, railroads canceled joint tariffs and transit rates and closed many interchange points. Conrail expected to increase its line-haul by cutting TP&W from the eastbound routing of Caterpillar machinery and parts after after canceling rates favoring the Logansport Gateway in 1981, but instead lost that business to Norfolk & Western. CR never recovered and shortly would reduce its service to alternate days and eliminate through train service altogether c. 1992. Locals out of Danville (Hillery) made runs to East Peoria thereafter.
N&W/NS lost business when they diverted Peoria and Bloomington-Normal traffic via Decatur in 1986 but began building it back by the 1990's. Diversion of traffic via Decatur didn't stop them from shifting most BNSF interchange at Chicago to Peoria in 1995. That move doubled train service on both the NS and BNSF lines to Peoria. Unfortunately, the Conrail Transaction gave NS an alternative and the heavy BNSF traffic was diverted away from Peoria.
Norfolk Southern's service issues following the Conrail breakup led to the discontinuance of their local intermodal service, which TP&W and CN happily snatched up. The Conrail breakup led to the end of Conrail haulage service to Peoria but it increased TP&W-CSXT routings.
Currently, competitive single-line NS and joint TP&W-CSXT routings are available to Peoria area shippers. There's some limited CN traffic to and from the east, mostly Michigan and Canada. Also, joint TP&W-CN intermodal service routes Caterpillar parts to Europe via the Port of Halifax.
DPJ
Rock Island "Suburban line" being tested the info is in the comments

Operation of Illinois' routes after the Rock shutdown. These comments are in a posting.
Steven Kakoczki The Iowa Railroad Co.
Remove
Harold J. Krewer After the Rock Island shut down, EJ&E operated Joliet-Bureau-Peoria for two months, ending 5/31/80. After the EJ&E pulled out, BN operated Peoria-Henry until Sept. 1981.

Remove
Harold J. Krewer From the second week of June until early August, the Winchester & Western (owned by Unimin Corp.) temporarily took over between Ottawa (BN) and LaSalle (ICG) to service Unimin's silica sand pit at Utica.

Remove
Harold J. Krewer Effective in early August, 1980, Baltimore & Ohio (NOT B&OCT) took over operating between Joliet and Bureau. They extended service to Henry in September 1981 after BN quit service from Peoria.

Remove
Harold J. Krewer Bureau-Silvis remained dormant (except for equipment moves by the RI Trustee) until Iowa Railroad (IRRC) extended service east to a B&O connection at Bureau in July 1982. IRRC was replaced by IAIS in November 1984 and IAIS operated its first train into Blue Island in April 1985.
IAIS restored service between Henry and Peoria in 1987.
CSX sub-leased MP 95 (Utica)-Bureau-Henry to IAIS in February 2006.


Remove
Harold J. Krewer Iowa Railroad (IRRC) never ran east of Bureau.


Markum to Schiller to "fondy" comments:

posting:  in the bunch of replies at the end
  • David DaruszkaDavid and 3 others manage the membership, moderators, settings, and posts for Chicago Railroad Historians. No offense taken. We were the only Chicago crew to run all the way from Markham to Fondy, and it took us all of 12 hours to do it. The hard part was getting through the Chicago terminal to Schiller Park. After that we were the hottest train on the railroad. Most trains in the Chicago terminal were handled by Chicago crews for that reason. The Wisconsin guys would get on at Schiller and take it the rest of the way. I didn't mind one road trip a week, but preferred to sleep in my own bed at night the rest of the time.
    1
  • Dave Ladislas Sr.Dave and 33 others joined Chicago Railroad Historians within the last two weeks. Give them a warm welcome into your community! David Daruszka ,oh,I recall those days.The Fondy crews used to love me,when possible,I'd pick them up at office,find their power,double up,and back home.They made my life easier and I'd do same for them.Schiller was brutal sumtimes,tho.Now,they take diff. route.
  • David DaruszkaDavid and 3 others manage the membership, moderators, settings, and posts for Chicago Railroad Historians. Depending on the old routing, neither was a picnic. Going through the C&NW and the B&OCT was a pain. Going via the CCP and the Harbor was a little better.
    2
  • Dave Ladislas Sr.Dave and 33 others joined Chicago Railroad Historians within the last two weeks. Give them a warm welcome into your community! David Daruszka ,most of that is gone now.I think they all take the EJ&E route to Joliet,then go North.We had no trains going N. via Harvey,etc. anymore.Even GT pig trains,they'd leave Harvey n head north thru Gary.I think CN either leased or sold what was known as the "Elsdon Sub",or down the hill,as I knew it.




posting: What is the eastern boundary of the GTW route that CN sold to CSX?    the junction with Monon, GT Crossing.

posting of video: NS Local at Racine and Pershing headed back to the Ashland Avenue Yard. Once they got on CJ2, they pulled onto the yard lead and shoved quite a ways back to Ashland.

posting of video: reactivated IHB wolf lake branch, NS Bernice cutoff, NS river branch

posting: North Clark Road in Gary, IN (Pine Junction) includes a .jpg of where it is legal to park. And advice on where else to railfan.

posting: CP 502 railfanning. This includes the pedestrian bridge.

Look at comments concerning Edward Kwiatkowski's comment in a Breski post concerning the BRC between their yard and Santa Fe and Chicago Junction. Of note:
Bob Lalich The line between Argo and the Stockyards has a complex history. It was built by the MC and became part of IHB. Part of the CR&I was either parallel to the IHB or used trackage rights from 49th and Oakley to Elsdon. The BRC line only went as far as Corwith. I believe BRC would have gone to USY via C&WI to 40th St, then the CJ.

Dennis DeBruler Edward Kwiatkowski I doubt it because Corwith is now an intermodal yard. Eola Yard and GM Yard is where BNSF handles local freight trains for their industry customers. Galesburg blocks freight trains to run directly to BRC's Clearing Yard and IHB's Blue Island for freight going to other railroads. One of the Galesburg trains takes the former CB&Q and the other takes the former Santa Fe. But I have forgotten which is which. I have learned how to take notes about places (yards, junctions, bridges, etc.) I'm still trying to figure out how to organize notes concerning train operations. Thus my confidence in these comments is not high because I'm doing it from memory from Facebook comments that I have read. Of course most BNSF freight is handled by through unit trains, intermodal or autoracks to Gibson Yard. Clearing and Blue Island handle the few merchandise trains that they still run.


Mike Breski posted
Bob Lalich When I first saw this John Barriger photo among his other IHB photos, I thought it may have been a WB at Francisco Ave in Blue Island. On second look, I wonder if it is an EB based on the sun and big block of reefers. I can't quite place the location.
Mike Breski Guessing could be by Pielet bros McCook Il with the 2 cranes and huge pile of what looks to be scrap in the backround. Blocked PFE came off CNW 246 train. East of Blue Island they would have been on their perspective NYC trains majority on NY2/Selkirk CG4/ Enola for daylight NY4 CG8 evenings.
Dennis DeBruler Thanks for explaining where the refers are probably coming from and going to. It makes this photo much more than just another train.
Rod and Bob discuss this C&WI South Deering Tower photo that I added to a post

Yesterday's CHC 156 (BNSF Cicero to NS Landers transfer) with a couple of FURX gp38s. This train was severely underpowered and crawled to a stop, stalling out by the Oak Lawn Metra Station at 95th st. Oak Lawn, Illinois - 2/2/19. (source) [I read somewhere that this transfer goes west to IHB, then south to Chicago Ridge where it gets on Metra's former Wabash line (SWS, Southwest Service) to NS/Wabash Landers yard.]
Dennis DeBruler Looks like the crossing gates would be down. What did they do next? Did they at least back up and release the gates? Blocking 95th Street would cause a lot of pain. Did NS send down a helper? I guess the good news is that the economy is strong enough that lots of cars would be in a transfer run.


Jon Roma commented on a Dennis DeBruler share     in Clinton Street Tower
Jon Roma Dennis DeBruler, there is no part of Clinton Street Tower that remains above track level. When it was closed around the turn of the century, UP massively reconfigured the tracks in the area to eliminate some of the complex specialwork, and replaced the old interlocking with three separate plants.

Northwest Jct. controls the divide between the six-track station throat and the two four-track mains. Halsted Street interlocking controls crossovers on the Illinois Division side, and Erie Street controls crossovers on the Wisconsin Division side. The three interlocking plants are controlled by the train director at Lake Street using a CRT system.

To be completely pedantic, it's inaccurate to refer to "C&NW Northwest Junction" since the modern plants did not replace Clinton Street Tower until about six years after C&NW was merged into UP.

There are just a handful of manned interlocking towers left in the Chicago area. On the former C&NW now operated by UP is Lake Street and CY (Clybourn). There's still A-2 and B-17 on the former Milwaukee Road.
16th Street Tower still holds firm, even though the building doesn't. The ex-Rock Island's Blue Island Tower is still in use. The former EJ&E JB Tower in West Chicago is still open. That's about it except for a few drawbridges where the operators still control signals.



Jon Roma commented on a post (the B&O bridge wreck)
Attached is a signal aspect and indication chart showing color position light signals. I scanned this from a employee timetable of the Baltimore & Ohio Chicago Terminal.
Dennis DeBruler A view of the west side that shows the massive counterweight and the bridge tower: https://www.flickr.com/.../in/album-72157655080811639/

Jon Roma The Color Position Signal is a reminder that this was B&O's initial passenger train route in
to Chicago. This is the first time I have seen a "backslash" set of lights. What color was used for that configuration? The signal mast also has the lone light on the top that is common with B&O signals. I have yet to learn how that modifies the basic stop (horizontal red), approach (diagonal yellow) and go (vertical green).Rod Truszkowski With a red signal and white light stop and proceedDennis DeBruler So the white light changes an absolute stop into a permissive stop.Rod Truszkowski Jon Roma I worked on the chicago short line at the time and was the general chairman for the union. The B&O was going to sell the bridge to the CSL for $500,00.00. The only business they had on the line was interchangeing cars with the CSL.IThe deal was all but signed when the wreck occured. The paperwork was on the desk of the CSL president that night and he was hemming and hawing about signing it. AS the story goes the B&O bridge tenders were not happy about losing their jobs as I was hoping to get them for our men. Needless to say the ship hit the bridge and the deal was off. The kicker to the story is there was a $2,000,000.00 insurance policy on the bridge for the owners. If the CSL had owned it they wold have made $1,500,000.00 over night. Instead the B&O got the $ and the CSL had to find a new way to get to some of their customers and the BRC.

This post also has info on Pere Marquette's Tracy and Rockwell yards because PM shared the B&O bridge. A comment has a map with the Tracy Yard. But I already have it.


This is one of several comments on a post (a worker got killed in a NS yard in Baltimore) about management and their rules.
Patrick McNamara Word from Proviso is that the Bosses don't like the current speed at which the operators are working - they have declared that 10 mph will be the speed or citations will be issued.


BNSF testing double-length grain trains  I wonder how fast they roll across road crossings.


Saturday, April 8, 2017

B&OCT History Details

Scott Griffith is finding interesting history details about the B&OCT faster than I can absorb them. So I'm recording the links here as reference material. To use this links, you will probably have to join the B&OCT RAILROAD group.

Old map that shows additional tracks around Altenheim and Bob's offer for the B&OCT history file

1955 B&OCT station code book #11

IHB tieing into the north side of the East Chicago yards

RIP house yard was once C yard

Interlocking tower at the north end of A yard at East Chicago

Location of freight office in C yard at East Chicago

Joint operations with Pennsy between State Line and Pine Junction

HS tower on the lake front, were we would have kept going north from the North A yard at East Chicago into Whiting

C&WI RR 47th St. Station 1905 Bot Lalich posted a map that shows where the stairwell to 47th street was. I posted a 1938 aerial.

1919 State Line to Bunham Ave.
A Lot of unknown history here. 
-There were tracks north of Brainard ave, 
-EJ&E had a yard here
-never heard of the Kensington and Eastern RR

Alt sub    Central Ave. area

48th Ave / Cicero    Satellite

Bob Lalich Cullen-Friedsted was located at 1300 S. Kilbourn Ave. This was the north end of BRC's 22nd St Yard.  Satellite

Northeast of the McCook crossing     It is now Fed Ex and a quarry hole    The initial posting for this area  Western Reduction   US Reduction in East Chicago was also switched by PRR and Wabash.

Freight Station at Chicago Heights question

Calumet Refinery

Edmier INC. 1951

G S Blakeslee & co.     Craig Holmberg A lot of industries in this area were reciprocal switching with the BRC. Also the B&O proper, had rights to switch this area but not for connection roads.

Mystery


Switcher 8418 switched Wyman-Gordon

1955    South Water Market

1948   U.S. SANITARY SPECIALTIES CORP

East Chicago

1929 Riverdale interlocking

General Foods

Whiting Branch 1955

Edison GE Appliance
Les Wuollett The northwest tip of 48th Ave Yard is above Gustave Lidseen bldg and just below B&OCT main. Upper left shows x'over to main which I think we called Central Ave when calling dispatcher to get a clearance. Even though CGW used the yard at the time B&OCT did the industry work. Run 52 (4pm) out of Homan did most of the work. They used the small yard (abt 1/2 dozen trks) located off 3rd main between Cicero Ave and BRC to line up cars and for storage.

22nd to 16th on the Blue Island subLes Wuollett I worked the 22nd st switchtender job on occasion. Would line up trains going from B&OCT to CB&Q. The CJ also had a switchtender who would complete line up toward CB&Q over the CJ trks. The shanty was very small and squeezed between the Pennsy and B&OCT trks. The clearance was so close that on the first day working there I would stand out side... Worried that any rocking cars might knock shanty down. However, the east bound road trains coming out of Robey St yard were still using steam locomotives and it would rain cinders... Stayed in shanty after that. lol

South Grant Spur

15th Place & Cicero  has quite a few comments about switching for connecting railroads.

Grant Wilson INC.

Burt Wheeling Brick

1918 Blueprint I just found in my collection of stuff I didn't even know I had of Dolton tower.

1915 Chicago Hieghts Blueprint. EJ&E, Chicago Hieghts Terminal Transfer, "? Central Railroad?
Bob Lalich Probably Michigan Central RR.

1912    Pine Jct                      1912    Pine Jct "Indiana" interlocking tower lever configuration

75th st

1915    Florence Spur in Hammond, IN.

Hill & Griffith industry     Manufacturer's junction railway lease

Metro Glass better know as Ball Glass to me

American Can Co. 1930

B&OCT & IHB interchange agreement 1931

Commercial Wallpaper Mill inc.   Hammond IN

Rockwell Engineering Co. 1950

BaumBach Electrocast steel Foundry

Midwest Beverage Co.

Humes & Berg manufacturer co.

Sears

Rosenbloom barrel & Drum

Earl Wacker I know where 149th & Loomis is on the Chgo Heights sub but there was never a swith there that I recall.




Louisville Cement Co.

What was this place at the east end of the south side East Chicago Yard at Baring ave?

B&OCT over new channel and SCAL still over old channel  Bob Lalich posted a photo of both bridges in-line

Crossovers between B&OCT and SCAL bridges



16th st. Bridge

Title Craft inc

H H walker & co.

Siding for Maremont Automotive Products

East Chicago water works (asking for help)

Barr Yard when only E yard was there

95th Street Crossing

Maremont Automotive Products      more track changes

Rock Island Junction

Pullman ave and Hammond st in Calumet Park?     The Bishop Ford Expy runs along the former Pullman Ave. It was the dividing line between Dolton and Calumet City.

NYC sand pit track

From WC to downtown

It's the Altenheim line between Western Ave tower and Rockwell St Jct.

Where my finger is pointing it is marked IHB RR. What!? 49th st?


Industrial Cinders at Pine Jct

Chicago Hieghts

B&O freight house #2

C&O Pere Marquette Freight House

Brookdale branch

Exhibit D: Panhandle crossed CJ RY just north of 49th

Never knew these tracks were at the East leg of the WYE going onto the Hieghts sub

The Foley Greenhouse Mfg. Co.

Central Ave before elevated

Ok This is up on the Lake front, but what the heck is a BUNK HOUSE never heard or saw one of these on a blue print

Jefferson Ice

Gary depot

Gary freight house

Bethlehem Steel

Rockwell Yard

Short cut over IC and CJ to stock yards and "GCS freight yard"

Dolton industrial spur

Rock Island Junction

International Harvester    Bob Lalich Just north of the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal at 31st St.

Says 16th St to the north and End of R/W to the south for B&OCT

Old North Hammond History

Central Ave before elevation or underpass

Whiting interlocking

Madison Ave station

Republic interlocking tower

49th Street

Chicago Avenue: Hammond Whiting & East Chicago Electric Railway

48th Avenue Yard

Euclid ave in East Chicago, didn't know this track layout existed

East Chicago roundhouse

Forest Park depot and tower

63rd Depot

East Chicago: now the north end of the Kankakee Line

Sunday, March 5, 2017

20170305 CGW Depot, Elmhurst, Twin CN&W locomotives

While working on a blog posting for Elmhurt's CGW's depot, I wondered if the building I saw on the satellite image was that depot. So I grabbed my camera and headed up York Street to determine if the depot has been preserved. It has.





The building in the satellite image where the Chicago, Aurora & Elgin depot used to be is now a park pavilion. Note the Illinois Prairie Path on the left that was built on the Row of the CA&E.
I turned 180-degrees and took a shot across York to show the park that Elmhurst has made from the abandoned RoWs of the CGW and CA&E, which used to run parallel to each other through here. That is the CGW depot you see peaking through the trees near the left and the Illinois Prairie Path on the right.
A view of the depot from the trail.
In this case the power companies evidently bought the edge of the RoWs because they existed while the tracks were still active. See the historical photo in the main blog.
I then went up York to see what downtown Elmhurst looked like. I knew that was where the UP/C&NW went through town. Traffic was stopped by a train. Before I could get parked, the engine had already gone by. It had just one locomotive.
It was a short train. This is just a few seconds later. Maybe it was short because it was a Sunday.
I took some pictures of the town's museum because it was a neat looking building. (Satellite) This is as far back as I could get without falling down an embankment to Robert Palmer Drive. Southeast corner.
Northeast corner.
I went down to Robert Palmer Drive to walk under the tracks to get on the north platform. This is a view of the north side of the museum from Metra's north platform.
I've lived in Downers Grove for over 40 years, but I have never been to downtown Elmhurst before. So this is an overview from near the east side of the Metra platform.
I had noticed headlights to the east when I arrived on the platform. The train finally started heading westbound.
It took a long time to arrive because it was going really slow.
It was going about twice as fast as I could comfortably walk.


Even though it was slow, I'm still having trouble with blurring. I need to pay better attention to my shutter speed. But I can still read the Placard number --- 1987.
1987 127 Alcohols, n.o.s.
1987 127 Denatured alcohol
A plaque on their Metra depot.
Slow trains leave you with a lot of time to kill. This seems to be the best shot of the depot that I got. It wasn't particularly photogenic.


It occurred to me that I could capture more of what downtown looked like and get the train.
It did start picking up speed near the end. In hindsight, it was leaving Proviso Yard, and it could not go up to track speed until its end had cleared the yard limit.
I took a sequence because I wanted to see how much of the downtown I could capture and still record that the train was passing.

Note the sky was clearing up to the west. Unfortunately, that clear sky never made its way east to Elmhurst.
(Facebooked) I learned from some railfans that the only two locomotives still in C&NW paint were expected eastbound. So I killed some time by walking past the shops on the south side of the tracks. There was an ice cream shop open in March. Before I finished eating my ice cream, the units arrived.
I shot early and often.


The above picture cropped
#8701  C44-9W

#8646  C44-9W

The above picture cropped
#7417  ES44AC, built 2009
It was another short train. The railfans explained that it came from Rochelle and left a cut of autoracks in West Chicago. It must have been a big cut to justify three locomotives. Because 19 containers don't need that kind of power.
I was taking pictures as I was walking back across Cottage Hill Avenue and towards the platform.




I started this trip with just one bar on my camera's battery. The plan was to checkout the CGW depot then go downtown/railfanning to run the battery down so that I could recharge it. Fortunately, I did have enough charge to get plenty of shots of "The Twins," as the railfans referred to the two C&NW livery locomotives.

I had been seeing some Facebook posting about two C&NW locomotives that the IRM was storing were taken back by UP. These are those units.

The Diesel Shop
Jimmy Bakes posted a Trains Mag link indicating The Twins are going to be repainted as generic UP locomotives. I can't read the link because I don't subscribe to Trains, but I can read the comments. Of note:
HAROLD KREWER
These two units dodged the paint booth for 22 years, thanks to the efforts of several ex-C&NW managers at UP that were their benefactors.

To be quite honest, their original paint is starting to get a bit ratty. The good folks at IRM tried to touch up a couple of the very worst spots while they were in storage as a goodwill gesture, but that only goes so far.

Whether or not these two ever do wind up in preservation remains to be seen, but if they do, they'll need a fresh coat of C&NW green and yellow either way, so what's the difference?

Better they get a fresh coat of yellow-and-gray that will protect the carbody from further rust and decay that let them turn to rustbuckets still wearing what's left of a 30+year-old paint job.

Don't be sad it's over, be glad it happened in the first place!